Werewolf by night worth one of my 1-2 generic gems?

BartenderKev

FrostGiantLord

I'd go with Hulk. Post-buff Hulk is a huge nuke, and he's an insane attacker for BGs, and is pretty solid without dupe. There are a few other solid options on there like Black Cat and Domino, but IMO Black Cat lacks utility and Domino needs dupe to really perform well. Maestro could also be a solid defender though.