My Ironheart honeymoon phase has ended
When she was first revealed, I was lovestruck with her kit, and she was one of my desired Titan pulls.
After pulling her, I thoroughly enjoyed Ironheart, and supported her even as detractors lamented her low damage and narrow rotation.
Even after the chance at being buffed came and went, I was still a fan.
But now .... I have fallen out of love.
I am generally a Utility over Damage guy, as I don't play much competitive modes where speed or big damage is important.
And while Ironheart's Utility >>> her Damage, there is this annoying thing where both can disappear at the same time.
Stacking 5 debuffs and keeping them paused with SP1 seems like it wouldn't be difficult, but with the AI playing keepaway or doing shallow intercepts, common timers that prevent applying debuffs (eg. unstoppable, miss, evade, etc), and common nodes that remove all buffs/debuffs/power, all this means it can be difficult to apply and maintain 5 debuffs.
And if I want to heavy to remove Prowess? I now have a shorter window to maintain debuffs, and with less debuffs, I can remove fewer Prowess.
Use utility > lose damage > lose utility > lose more damage.
Choosing Utility vs Big Damage is not unique to Ironheart. What is unique to her is that her Utility and Damage (the DoT) can disappear even if one skips the Big Damage loop. Stick with SP1 to maintain Utility, but even then, my debuffs can fall off even if I am focused on SP1, because of the defender or node abilities.
And even when I choose to "cashout' on my utility by going for the SP2 damage, it seems a bit underwhelming even after stacking a bunch of debuffs (I encounter the same problem with Rintrah, where the SP2 damage after stacking ruptures doesn't seem to hit as hard as it should).
And this is made worse by the fact that her more 'permanent' utilities can easily be turned off by champions and nodes (armor breaks, nullifies, etc). Her sig Regen ability also seems underpowered (compared to other Tech champions) to where the opponent can easily outdamage the regen rate.
The final cherry on top of all this is seeing the next dating show contestant, Jack o Lantern, having similar Utility without needing to sacrifice Damage.