Who would win #14

OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★

Who would win #14 67 votes

Jessica Jones
38%
thetaman23TerraAhitlawDuke_SilverLordScatsburyTaZ_4178ArkhamButcherhiddenblizzardMCoC_fanshadow_lurker22Kobster84PrylankAleorRockypantherxWoogieboogieChainslayerBatman1903EtjamaZuroUmbertoDelRio 26 votes
Black widow
61%
Haji_SaabSundance_2099FingfangfoomfanesNojokejaymCliffordcanStingerbkSpiderCoolsErkCupidTheMarauder53Jackbrooks2580LordRaymond3Mitchell35Markg25FhfjghhggggjfhfjgTheSpicyKnightTony886Webby72ManfréaBolgenSPIDERMANANTMAN 41 votes
«1

Comments

  • DjkrdjjDjkrdjj Posts: 294
    edited July 12
    Jessica Jones
    Does JJ have super powers?
    Plus BW freakin sucks, hater her
  • Too_qikToo_qik Posts: 268
    Black widow
    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.
  • DjkrdjjDjkrdjj Posts: 294
    Jessica Jones
    Too_qik said:

    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.

    What are JJs powers
    I thought she had like super strength and immunities or aomething
  • FingfangfoomfanesFingfangfoomfanes Posts: 1,034 ★★★
    Black widow
    BW. Subtlety. JJ - unreleased meta.
  • DjkrdjjDjkrdjj Posts: 294
    Jessica Jones

    BW. Subtlety. JJ - unreleased meta.

    I’m was told these fights are out of game fights
  • Kobster84Kobster84 Posts: 2,452 ★★★★
    Jessica Jones
    Jessica Jones has super strength limited invulnerability and flight
  • Duke_SilverDuke_Silver Posts: 1,305 ★★★
    Jessica Jones
    She’s got powers doesn’t she?
  • OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★
    The way i see it. Jessica Jones got her powers yes super strength and all. But BW is a highly trained Assassin and JJ can still die. Nobody said BW had to fight "fair"
  • shadow_lurker22shadow_lurker22 Posts: 2,001 ★★★★
    Jessica Jones
    Too_qik said:

    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.

    It is quite clear you only watch the movies.
  • AhitlawAhitlaw Posts: 1,445 ★★★
    Jessica Jones
    These posts are pointless at this point, even though I enjoy them the votes always go to the most popular character. JJ would make BW her ****
  • DjkrdjjDjkrdjj Posts: 294
    Jessica Jones

    Too_qik said:

    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.

    It is quite clear you only watch the movies.
    Chill I only voted for JJ becuz I thought she had some sort of immunities. JJs tv show was so boring I don’t blame him for not knowing about her
  • shadow_lurker22shadow_lurker22 Posts: 2,001 ★★★★
    Jessica Jones
    Djkrdjj said:

    Too_qik said:

    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.

    It is quite clear you only watch the movies.
    Chill I only voted for JJ becuz I thought she had some sort of immunities. JJs tv show was so boring I don’t blame him for not knowing about her
    1 Eh I'm not just talking about this post.
    2 I've never seen that show either I was more referring to the Comics
    3 I am not mad at all just pointing it out
  • ZuroZuro Posts: 981 ★★★
    Jessica Jones
    Djkrdjj said:

    Too_qik said:

    Black widow has been trained by sheild themselves, the answer is obvious here.

    It is quite clear you only watch the movies.
    Chill I only voted for JJ becuz I thought she had some sort of immunities. JJs tv show was so boring I don’t blame him for not knowing about her
    I dont even think he was talking to you
  • X_Factor_AgentX_Factor_Agent Posts: 1,140 ★★★
    Black widow
    Jessica Jones can't fight. Sorry, but Black widow wins here. Shield agents are trained to be able to take on multiple physically stronger people at the same time. JJ is just this one person.
  • RockypantherxRockypantherx Posts: 366 ★★
    Jessica Jones
    Oh, I thought we were talking about a drinking contest, never mind me...
  • WoogieboogieWoogieboogie Posts: 166
    Jessica Jones
    Jessica could get 1 grab or 1 punch and knock her down. Luke would do the same
  • OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★

    Jessica could get 1 grab or 1 punch and knock her down. Luke would do the same

    There is a difference between cage and jones tho. I agree if JJ gets a hold on BW its over. But i dont think she will get the chance
  • UmbertoDelRioUmbertoDelRio Posts: 1,364 ★★★
    Jessica Jones
    I mean... All jones would need to do is get a hold of black widow.

    One good punch should be enough. And can't she even fly as well? There isn't much black widow could do, unless jessica is bloodlusted and black widow highly focussed.

    If they're on equal terms jones wins 10/10.
  • BrudixTreeBrudixTree Posts: 573
    Jessica Jones
    The one with the bigger bombs if you know what i mean 😏
  • RagnabroRagnabro Posts: 20
    Jessica Jones
    JJ can one shot BW
  • OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★
    I think everyone who says JJ hands down forgets shes not immune to bullets, these posts isnt about cage fights where they start fighting in a small area hand to hand, it is open to suggestion of scenarios.

    Anyone stating it would be easy for Jones can you please tell me what would stop BW from sniping her ass down a mile away? im seriously asking
  • LordBeaverbrokeLordBeaverbroke Posts: 223 ★★
    Black widow
    Black Widow has guns, Jessica Jones, despite being on a team with Daredevil and Luke Cage, is neither bulletproof nor capable of dodging bullets
  • UmbertoDelRioUmbertoDelRio Posts: 1,364 ★★★
    Jessica Jones

    I think everyone who says JJ hands down forgets shes not immune to bullets, these posts isnt about cage fights where they start fighting in a small area hand to hand, it is open to suggestion of scenarios.

    Anyone stating it would be easy for Jones can you please tell me what would stop BW from sniping her ass down a mile away? im seriously asking

    What would stop her? Well first of the lack of information your post provides.

    If there's no clearly determined circumstances of the fight, then we basically have to assume that they start out on a plane field about 100 meters apart trying to kill each other.

    Here's an example for how you could have done this in a way that even made bullets a real factor:

    Agent romanoff gets ordered to kill jessica jones. She has 1 week (?) of preparation time and can basically choose the area in which she'll make her first attempt to take a hit on JJ.
    JJ gets a bit of inside information (probably barton couldn't keep his mouth shut) and knows that someone is ordered to take her out.

    An example for additional information further influencing the fight:

    Morals on and JJ is with her baby.

    That could actually a somewhat fair matchup.
  • LordBeaverbrokeLordBeaverbroke Posts: 223 ★★
    Black widow

    I think everyone who says JJ hands down forgets shes not immune to bullets, these posts isnt about cage fights where they start fighting in a small area hand to hand, it is open to suggestion of scenarios.

    Anyone stating it would be easy for Jones can you please tell me what would stop BW from sniping her ass down a mile away? im seriously asking

    What would stop her? Well first of the lack of information your post provides.

    If there's no clearly determined circumstances of the fight, then we basically have to assume that they start out on a plane field about 100 meters apart trying to kill each other.

    Here's an example for how you could have done this in a way that even made bullets a real factor:

    Agent romanoff gets ordered to kill jessica jones. She has 1 week (?) of preparation time and can basically choose the area in which she'll make her first attempt to take a hit on JJ.
    JJ gets a bit of inside information (probably barton couldn't keep his mouth shut) and knows that someone is ordered to take her out.

    An example for additional information further influencing the fight:

    Morals on and JJ is with her baby.

    That could actually a somewhat fair matchup.
    Black widow has a grey moral compass. That is an integral part of her character in both the comics and the MCU. I'm not saying that she would not have qualms about killing a pregnant mother, but she could still do it.
  • UmbertoDelRioUmbertoDelRio Posts: 1,364 ★★★
    Jessica Jones
    Additionally, without further information we have to assume that they both use their standard equipment.
    Widow doesn't regularly carry around a sniper rifle.

    Standard equipment should include normal 9mm pistols.

    And superhuman durability definitely is one of JJ's traits. Yes, she isn't bulletproof, at least she wasn't depicted to be that yet, but knifes can hardly damage her. So it would definitely be possible, but take more than for a normal human. And there's no reason she couldn't just fly around to make herself a way harder target.
  • OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★

    Additionally, without further information we have to assume that they both use their standard equipment.
    Widow doesn't regularly carry around a sniper rifle.

    Standard equipment should include normal 9mm pistols.

    And superhuman durability definitely is one of JJ's traits. Yes, she isn't bulletproof, at least she wasn't depicted to be that yet, but knifes can hardly damage her. So it would definitely be possible, but take more than for a normal human. And there's no reason she couldn't just fly around to make herself a way harder target.

    As i told you in one of the other of these posts stop assuming. Im giving no information so that you can create whatever scenario you like. What would it take for bw to win and where and vise versa and etc etc. Its all up to each individual where it takes place and the circumstances. I only want people to engage and show their true nerdiness. I like it and find it fun
  • UmbertoDelRioUmbertoDelRio Posts: 1,364 ★★★
    Jessica Jones

    I think everyone who says JJ hands down forgets shes not immune to bullets, these posts isnt about cage fights where they start fighting in a small area hand to hand, it is open to suggestion of scenarios.

    Anyone stating it would be easy for Jones can you please tell me what would stop BW from sniping her ass down a mile away? im seriously asking

    What would stop her? Well first of the lack of information your post provides.

    If there's no clearly determined circumstances of the fight, then we basically have to assume that they start out on a plane field about 100 meters apart trying to kill each other.

    Here's an example for how you could have done this in a way that even made bullets a real factor:

    Agent romanoff gets ordered to kill jessica jones. She has 1 week (?) of preparation time and can basically choose the area in which she'll make her first attempt to take a hit on JJ.
    JJ gets a bit of inside information (probably barton couldn't keep his mouth shut) and knows that someone is ordered to take her out.

    An example for additional information further influencing the fight:

    Morals on and JJ is with her baby.

    That could actually a somewhat fair matchup.
    Black widow has a grey moral compass. That is an integral part of her character in both the comics and the MCU. I'm not saying that she would not have qualms about killing a pregnant mother, but she could still do it.
    Do you see where I'm getting at, though?

    Those two aren't exactly a fair matchup by themselves. They have different methods, different weaknesses, etc.

    That's why you need a stricter playing field.
    If they're fighting on an open field with standard equipment, starting 100m apart aiming at incapacitating their opponent, JJ would have a massive advantage.

    If you throw both of them in a big city, give black widow access to practically the whole armory of shield, or at least any standard weapon she ever used or is able to use, there wouldn't be much JJ could do.

    It's a bad matchup to be honest, so I kinda tried to make it work.
  • UmbertoDelRioUmbertoDelRio Posts: 1,364 ★★★
    Jessica Jones

    Additionally, without further information we have to assume that they both use their standard equipment.
    Widow doesn't regularly carry around a sniper rifle.

    Standard equipment should include normal 9mm pistols.

    And superhuman durability definitely is one of JJ's traits. Yes, she isn't bulletproof, at least she wasn't depicted to be that yet, but knifes can hardly damage her. So it would definitely be possible, but take more than for a normal human. And there's no reason she couldn't just fly around to make herself a way harder target.

    As i told you in one of the other of these posts stop assuming. Im giving no information so that you can create whatever scenario you like. What would it take for bw to win and where and vise versa and etc etc. Its all up to each individual where it takes place and the circumstances. I only want people to engage and show their true nerdiness. I like it and find it fun
    No offense, but... Stop assuming AND make up your own scenario? That simply doesn't work.

    You can do this however you like, it's just pretty much useless and leaves no chance for an actual conclusion, since "jessica jones is way stronger and more durable" can be countered with "but black widow can just snipe her in the head 10 times from a shield helicarrier duh".
  • OneManArmyOneManArmy Posts: 1,867 ★★★★

    Additionally, without further information we have to assume that they both use their standard equipment.
    Widow doesn't regularly carry around a sniper rifle.

    Standard equipment should include normal 9mm pistols.

    And superhuman durability definitely is one of JJ's traits. Yes, she isn't bulletproof, at least she wasn't depicted to be that yet, but knifes can hardly damage her. So it would definitely be possible, but take more than for a normal human. And there's no reason she couldn't just fly around to make herself a way harder target.

    As i told you in one of the other of these posts stop assuming. Im giving no information so that you can create whatever scenario you like. What would it take for bw to win and where and vise versa and etc etc. Its all up to each individual where it takes place and the circumstances. I only want people to engage and show their true nerdiness. I like it and find it fun
    No offense, but... Stop assuming AND make up your own scenario? That simply doesn't work.

    You can do this however you like, it's just pretty much useless and leaves no chance for an actual conclusion, since "jessica jones is way stronger and more durable" can be countered with "but black widow can just snipe her in the head 10 times from a shield helicarrier duh".
    Im sorry im not from a English speaking country so i am a bit limited and sometimes the things im saying doesnt come of how i mean them to.
    Im just interested in seeing different views and yes scenarios as im certain both could win under different circumstanses if that makes sense. Would have to be somewhat likely tho and maybe a criteria that both is aware a fight is going to take place but not neccessary that they start at the same place if any of this made sense
  • LordBeaverbrokeLordBeaverbroke Posts: 223 ★★
    Black widow

    I think everyone who says JJ hands down forgets shes not immune to bullets, these posts isnt about cage fights where they start fighting in a small area hand to hand, it is open to suggestion of scenarios.

    Anyone stating it would be easy for Jones can you please tell me what would stop BW from sniping her ass down a mile away? im seriously asking

    What would stop her? Well first of the lack of information your post provides.

    If there's no clearly determined circumstances of the fight, then we basically have to assume that they start out on a plane field about 100 meters apart trying to kill each other.

    Here's an example for how you could have done this in a way that even made bullets a real factor:

    Agent romanoff gets ordered to kill jessica jones. She has 1 week (?) of preparation time and can basically choose the area in which she'll make her first attempt to take a hit on JJ.
    JJ gets a bit of inside information (probably barton couldn't keep his mouth shut) and knows that someone is ordered to take her out.

    An example for additional information further influencing the fight:

    Morals on and JJ is with her baby.

    That could actually a somewhat fair matchup.
    Black widow has a grey moral compass. That is an integral part of her character in both the comics and the MCU. I'm not saying that she would not have qualms about killing a pregnant mother, but she could still do it.
    Do you see where I'm getting at, though?

    Those two aren't exactly a fair matchup by themselves. They have different methods, different weaknesses, etc.

    That's why you need a stricter playing field.
    If they're fighting on an open field with standard equipment, starting 100m apart aiming at incapacitating their opponent, JJ would have a massive advantage.

    If you throw both of them in a big city, give black widow access to practically the whole armory of shield, or at least any standard weapon she ever used or is able to use, there wouldn't be much JJ could do.

    It's a bad matchup to be honest, so I kinda tried to make it work.
    Black Widow's Widow stingers are equipped with both tear gas and an unknown gas that makes people unconscious. While Jones has physical immunity, I do not believe she has immunity to chemical attacks.
Sign In or Register to comment.