AW calculations
The alliance war points make it virtually impossible for an alliance with a lower alliance rating to win, unless the higher alliance is really terrible at fighting and refuses to use resources, or unless they completely bungle their defense, either in terms of diversity or defender rating.
This is just math. You have broken war by making it a simple math exercise whereby the higher ranked alliance should ALWAYS win. This is why war is broken.
Unless you find a way to reintroduce skill into the equation, war will remain broken.