Just because you're looking at magneto as a magnet ... Let's apply physics ....his power allows him to control all metal. SS is Cosmic metal end of story.
Not all magnets attract all metals. Also, as said above, SS isn't actually cosmic metal.
Listen I agree to disagree ... I stated the facts why I think SS should be #metal
You stated opinions. Not a single fact. Great thing about opinions is that they can be wrong. Like yours. And the ones who actually know the facts can laugh at you when you refused to believe them.
You are like a flat earther in a group that knows the world is not.
I don't argue with people who are flat out wrong. I just make make feel really stupid until they realise they're wrong and correct themselves. It's much more satisfying that way.
So, interesting question, but I would like to weigh in from the comic book point of view since I’ve been part of this discussion many times.
I only have Silver Surfer #1, and I don’t open it but we can all go online to various comic book reading apps and websites and read the Silver Surfer limited run in the late 1960’s that were created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.
Although I don’t remember which issue specifically, I can say with confidence that when Galactus imbued Norrin Radd with the “Power Cosmic”, Radd became this all powerful being which was connected to Galactus through the “Power Cosmic”. The appearance of the Surfer, a silvery color, is supposed to be a manifestation of the energy he possesses but more importantly a representation of the form of heroes that Norrin Radd read about and heard stories about as he was growing up. Meaning the power he got manifested in that way mimicking his childhood heroes. It is furthermore controlled only by the Power Cosmic until Galactus releases Radd by trapping him on Earth as punishment for defying him.
It’s not supposed to be actual metal, according to the comic books. It’s a power taking the form of whatever it wants, in this case Radd’s childhood memories.
Supposedly it makes him immune to poisons as well - so it annoys me that he’s not poison immune, but hey - that’s another discussion.
Anyway, I remember most of that from when I was younger. Unfortunately I don’t have the Power Cosmic and I don’t look like my childhood heroes.
The Silver Surfer's skin is made out of cosmic powered silver metal that could be handled and modified only if one possesses the Power Cosmic. It reacts to a person's thoughts. When the metal came into contact with Norrin Radd, it took the form of Norrin's childhood superhero. Ntmu Fluffy Pig Monster
The Silver Surfer's skin is made out of cosmic powered silver metal that could be handled and modified only if one possesses the Power Cosmic. It reacts to a person's thoughts. When the metal came into contact with Norrin Radd, it took the form of Norrin's childhood superhero. Ntmu Fluffy Pig Monster
Likewise, buddy. I wasn’t trying to contradict anyone - just info from a comic book nerd! I still don’t understand how some champs with guns aren’t #metal and how Dormammu isn’t incinerate immune and stuff like that.
The Silver Surfer's skin is made out of cosmic powered silver metal that could be handled and modified only if one possesses the Power Cosmic. It reacts to a person's thoughts. When the metal came into contact with Norrin Radd, it took the form of Norrin's childhood superhero. Ntmu Fluffy Pig Monster
Likewise, buddy. I wasn’t trying to contradict anyone - just info from a comic book nerd! I still don’t understand how some champs with guns aren’t #metal and how Dormammu isn’t incinerate immune and stuff like that.
The Silver Surfer's skin is made out of cosmic powered silver metal that could be handled and modified only if one possesses the Power Cosmic. It reacts to a person's thoughts. When the metal came into contact with Norrin Radd, it took the form of Norrin's childhood superhero. Ntmu Fluffy Pig Monster
Likewise, buddy. I wasn’t trying to contradict anyone - just info from a comic book nerd! I still don’t understand how some champs with guns aren’t #metal and how Dormammu isn’t incinerate immune and stuff like that.
By your logic. Silver paint is metal? Dont need to be toxic when it’s just feedback bro. Just because he has silver in his name doesnt make him metal. Gold pool is in a gold suit. Is it made of real gold? No.
By your logic. Silver paint is metal? Dont need to be toxic when it’s just feedback bro. Just because he has silver in his name doesnt make him metal. Gold pool is in a gold suit. Is it made of real gold? No.
I wish Goldpool was just Red Deadpool. I’d like a 5* and 6* version of a Red Deadpool. It would be nice to play and rank up and stuff.
Iirc - silver surfer isn’t made of a magnetic metal - it’s a metal that only interacts with someone with the power cosmic - essentially it’s a ‘space metal’ that’s cosmically powered by the power cosmic - and isn’t magnetic.
Although I could be wrong. It’s been a while since I’ve read anything about silver surfer.
I'm glad you checked Google that shows me how intelligent you are.
Oh really now, insulting someone for using Google? And since you clearly haven't seen or read Any Story with Magneto in it, prey tell where you learned your "100% Factual" Information from other than Google good sir or madam?
You're making your own rules it clearly States he controls all metal
"They're making up their own rules" Because if you had seen or read practically Any Story Containing Magneto you'd know his Powers are Much Much More than simply "controls all metal" (like how he can disrupt the Interworking of a Body's Nerves System by basically creating an EMP in a Brain causing Seizures which he once did to The Freaking Phoenix), as well you'd know there are plenty of Metals he cannot Manipulate (due to his Powers being *Total Control of Magnetic/Electro-Magnetic Fields* and not simply "controls all metals") for example Vibranium like apart of BP's Suit or Enchanted Uru like Thor's Hammer.
Continue the deny Factual Information with short childish "Nuh-uhhs" as you wish, but it doesn't change the fact that Magneto Does Not "Control All Metal" and Kabam will Never add the Metal Tag to Silver Surfer. (Especially if they aren't going to add it to Professor X who has A Giant Metal Ball on his Head that we've seen Magneto Manipulate Several Times now... 😂)
Comments
You are like a flat earther in a group that knows the world is not.
Can confirm. This guy praised me for using google in the last page./s
I doubt you know much about the comics if you can’t figure out that Silver isn’t magnetic
Agreed
This is like Him Saying Magneto should be #Metal because he has the Word “Magnet” in his name 🤣
I vote they just remove metal from guardian cause he isn't metal and then leave it alone.
I only have Silver Surfer #1, and I don’t open it but we can all go online to various comic book reading apps and websites and read the Silver Surfer limited run in the late 1960’s that were created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.
Although I don’t remember which issue specifically, I can say with confidence that when Galactus imbued Norrin Radd with the “Power Cosmic”, Radd became this all powerful being which was connected to Galactus through the “Power Cosmic”. The appearance of the Surfer, a silvery color, is supposed to be a manifestation of the energy he possesses but more importantly a representation of the form of heroes that Norrin Radd read about and heard stories about as he was growing up. Meaning the power he got manifested in that way mimicking his childhood heroes. It is furthermore controlled only by the Power Cosmic until Galactus releases Radd by trapping him on Earth as punishment for defying him.
It’s not supposed to be actual metal, according to the comic books. It’s a power taking the form of whatever it wants, in this case Radd’s childhood memories.
Supposedly it makes him immune to poisons as well - so it annoys me that he’s not poison immune, but hey - that’s another discussion.
Anyway, I remember most of that from when I was younger. Unfortunately I don’t have the Power Cosmic and I don’t look like my childhood heroes.
Hope that helps.
The Silver Surfer's skin is made out of cosmic powered silver metal that could be handled and modified only if one possesses the Power Cosmic. It reacts to a person's thoughts. When the metal came into contact with Norrin Radd, it took the form of Norrin's childhood superhero. Ntmu Fluffy Pig Monster
Although I could be wrong. It’s been a while since I’ve read anything about silver surfer.
So no #metal
And since you clearly haven't seen or read Any Story with Magneto in it, prey tell where you learned your "100% Factual" Information from other than Google good sir or madam? "They're making up their own rules"
Because if you had seen or read practically Any Story Containing Magneto you'd know his Powers are Much Much More than simply "controls all metal" (like how he can disrupt the Interworking of a Body's Nerves System by basically creating an EMP in a Brain causing Seizures which he once did to The Freaking Phoenix), as well you'd know there are plenty of Metals he cannot Manipulate (due to his Powers being *Total Control of Magnetic/Electro-Magnetic Fields* and not simply "controls all metals") for example Vibranium like apart of BP's Suit or Enchanted Uru like Thor's Hammer.
Continue the deny Factual Information with short childish "Nuh-uhhs" as you wish, but it doesn't change the fact that Magneto Does Not "Control All Metal" and Kabam will Never add the Metal Tag to Silver Surfer. (Especially if they aren't going to add it to Professor X who has A Giant Metal Ball on his Head that we've seen Magneto Manipulate Several Times now... 😂)