Can this be fixed? Or am I a crazy dreamer?

Tylermcbain

Just became cavalier but had already done the objectives. Does it get sorted or do we abandon all hope

SummonerNR

You didn’t have the objective available for (insert missing T.L. # Objective here) until AFTER you had already completed the quest while still (insert previous Progression Title here).

After that is when you must have become (insert newly reached Progression Title here), and so it doesn’t reward newly available objectives retroactively after you advance to new progressions.

Just like your Calendar doesn’t upgrade to next progression level of stuff until the whole month rolls over.

Try submitting a Support Ticket, they seem to be giving into these type of requests this month.