Morning Star Soul Capture not working
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/62d2c/62d2c7a10fb7c3eebd640f824a3e1ef1f8842f74" alt="BronxHugeth"
Just did story mode fight with Morning Star and used my L3 and won the fight, but it never registered the soul capture on the next fight. Should it register 1 after the 1st fight in the little blue box?
0