Should we kick the player who cost us this war?
linux
Member Posts: 302 ★
We use a spreadsheet to assign champs for full diversity. One of our players changed his champs without checking who'd placed or telling us, producing a dupe -- the cost of that missed opportunity was greater than the margin of our loss. (Granted, that's only because our opponents did the same thing, but the point of this poll is to focus on how we can improve.)
Should we kick the player who placed the wrong champ?
Should we kick the player who placed the wrong champ?
Should we kick the player who cost us this war? 162 votes
Yes -- since champ selection decides wars, we should drop players who don't take it seriously
11%
18 votes
No -- everyone makes mistakes occasionally ... it's just usually not so obvious when a mistake costs you the war
27%
44 votes
Maybe -- give them a strike, and kick them if they get 3 strikes
23%
38 votes
No -- this AW format is horrible and we should focus on getting Kabam to change it
38%
62 votes
1
Comments
The boosts don't work, but they do affect defender rating.
#sarcasm
If they have a good history, then tease them mercilessly so they learn their lesson and are an example to others, but don't boot them just yet.
EXACTLY.
I was talking about the person who created the 149 champ diversity. My understanding was that you lost based on defender rating and not diversity. So whoever created 149 champ diversity placement and not 150 should get kicked. My comment was also sarcastic.
Insert serious business jpeg here.
And I don't care if you kick him. Not my circus.
Don't ruin it.
#1 how long has this member been a part of the group?
#2 how was their past performance/participation in general?
#3 has this member been cooperative and willing to help the group when called upon?
#4 have they displayed a lack of "team player" attitude as percieved by the leaders?
#5 how vital have they been to the groups overall growth(ie.. They rank top 50% or better in alliance events consistently)?
#6 If in fact his actions can be fully justified as the reason for losing the war, does the pros/cons hold less weight compared to losing one match of AW?
#7 has this member took ownership of having made a mistake and willing to avoid it happening again?
BTW, This has really nothing to do with "feelings getting hurt". IMO It has more to do with good ethics and common courtesy because they are as vital as any other member of the group.Good luck to you in making a decision!