Who should I take to r4?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d399a/d399ab284ea7d6e33f1959cd7fef7b674776a428" alt="anon1123"
Both of these champs (carnage and SG) are 4*. I know they're not the greatest but so far it's all I have to work with
should I bother taking them to r4 or just save my tier 4 base catalysts for when I get a better 4*??
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fc65c/fc65cb27ea625d73b72e8b6356e73fd2a38ccf17" alt=":/ :/"
Who should I take to r4? 23 votes
carnage
13%
3 votes
spidergwen
21%
5 votes
neither
65%
15 votes
0
Comments
Carnage takes a long time to accumulate permanent buffs, fight is often over earlier.
SG has stun so gives a window for stun (parry), special 3, combo. Maybe better than Carnage in short fights.
Save the catalyst for other champs.