Mutant Dual Threat Supremacy

Polygon

Rate these 3 mutants from Best to Worst as Dual Threats in BGs.

If you think the order would change if it was looking at defender value instead, comment below.

Fyi I left out a few mutants to keep it simple and down to 3, but Domino would make it a no brainer. Left out NC and Bishop since they're not too difficult on defense. Could make an argument for Bishop, but his main difficulty is the bad AI in throwing sp1

Emilia90

Onslaught > Dust > Mr Sinister

Onslaught > Dust > Sinister (inequity) and Onslaught > Sinister > Dust (no inequity)

ItsClobberinTime

Mr Sinister > Onslaught > Dust

This is hard because Onslaught isn't exactly a nuke but Sinister also can't nuke if there's Inequity, 30 sec fights turn into 40-55 sec fights.
Since you're asking for best dual threat and not defender or attacker only, I'd say:
No Inequity ➡️ Sinister, Onslaught, Dust
Yes Inequity ➡️ Onslaught, Sinister, Dust
Dust is very slow, even slower than Sinister with Inequity unless ofc it's a r3 Dust which is extremely rare cause why would anyone do that lmao

Polygon

ItsClobberinTime said:

This is hard because Onslaught isn't exactly a nuke but Sinister also can't nuke if there's Inequity, 30 sec fights turn into 40-55 sec fights.
Since you're asking for best dual threat and not defender or attacker only, I'd say:
No Inequity ➡️ Sinister, Onslaught, Dust
Yes Inequity ➡️ Onslaught, Sinister, Dust
Dust is very slow, even slower than Sinister with Inequity unless ofc it's a r3 Dust which is extremely rare cause why would anyone do that lmao

What would your defense only line up be?

ItsClobberinTime

Mr Sinister > Onslaught > Dust

Polygon said:

ItsClobberinTime said:

This is hard because Onslaught isn't exactly a nuke but Sinister also can't nuke if there's Inequity, 30 sec fights turn into 40-55 sec fights.
Since you're asking for best dual threat and not defender or attacker only, I'd say:
No Inequity ➡️ Sinister, Onslaught, Dust
Yes Inequity ➡️ Onslaught, Sinister, Dust
Dust is very slow, even slower than Sinister with Inequity unless ofc it's a r3 Dust which is extremely rare cause why would anyone do that lmao

What would your defense only line up be?

Defense only, Onslaught Dust Sinister. I'd want all three in my deck though cause they're all very strong on defense, so if you have all three take them.