My group is platinum 1 all season before and after the hammer came down. 5-2 and our only 2 losses have come against you guessed it, alliances that were penalized for cheating.
The most recent loss was against a Master group that was brought down.
While we may not be the top of the top, platinum 1 still puts us in the top 50. So from a top 50 group.......
These rating drops are NOT a good thing. Drop their points, leave their rating and possibly drop their multiplier if that's possible to code.
This punishment is punishing clean alliances as well as the groups that cheat.....
Exactly. The worst is this happens when an alliance can still swap out members with new blood that still qualify for rewards.
And then consecutive wins happens during the last 5 wars with potentially huge points gained from beating a much weaker alliance not even able to finish 50% of the war. Real fair
Here are our last 3 wars. First was right before the hammer, which we actually should have won if one guy didn't MIA for the last 6 hours and force us to fight through links, that guy is obviously gone now.
Back on topic.
I'm not blaming these groups and have no ill will towards them, they're taking advantage of a flawed system. There are of course some groups that have no idea they had a bad egg and for those groups, it sucks but not as much as the clean groups they're going to roll for the rest of the season. Really is no reason NOT to cheat because if you do and get caught you've got an easy second half and can still get almost top rewards. If you don't you get top rewards.
This "punishment" affects the 6 groups that will be rolled until end of season. The current penalty is not correct and needs to be fixed.
Dock points
Leave rating alone
Drop multiplier
Second war against a Master alliance that got hit
Current war against ANOTHER Master alliance that got hit
I'm all for stepping it up against top 10 groups but when my group has the same rating.....2600 versus a group that was 3k....tough to say the least.
Comments
The most recent loss was against a Master group that was brought down.
While we may not be the top of the top, platinum 1 still puts us in the top 50. So from a top 50 group.......
These rating drops are NOT a good thing. Drop their points, leave their rating and possibly drop their multiplier if that's possible to code.
This punishment is punishing clean alliances as well as the groups that cheat.....
3rd in a row, definitely working as intended.
And then consecutive wins happens during the last 5 wars with potentially huge points gained from beating a much weaker alliance not even able to finish 50% of the war. Real fair
Back on topic.
I'm not blaming these groups and have no ill will towards them, they're taking advantage of a flawed system. There are of course some groups that have no idea they had a bad egg and for those groups, it sucks but not as much as the clean groups they're going to roll for the rest of the season. Really is no reason NOT to cheat because if you do and get caught you've got an easy second half and can still get almost top rewards. If you don't you get top rewards.
This "punishment" affects the 6 groups that will be rolled until end of season. The current penalty is not correct and needs to be fixed.
Dock points
Leave rating alone
Drop multiplier
Second war against a Master alliance that got hit
Current war against ANOTHER Master alliance that got hit
I'm all for stepping it up against top 10 groups but when my group has the same rating.....2600 versus a group that was 3k....tough to say the least.
Win or lose, this system is broken.