Nick Fury/Quake Synergy: Strategic Sabotage broken?

I use this synergy a lot in both my accounts. It works for basic attacks as far as I can tell. But often when failing to block a special attack my champion gets clipped. At first I thought maybe the specials were multihit and using up the evade charges but after getting hit I still have evade charges left. That shouldn't happen right? 

1
Comments
1. No special nodes active.
2. No true strike or anything that cancels evades
3. Happens anywhere. ROL, LOL, Arenas, Events etc.