Should Rogue be able to Replicate Emma F. Diamond Form?

JDunk2291JDunk2291 Posts: 199
edited September 2018 in Suggestions and Requests
Just Curious and i think it would be awesome to see Rogue in a Stolen Diamond form lol

Should Rogue be able to Replicate Emma F. Diamond Form? 57 votes

Yes
61%
Whododo872mostlyharmlessnThestoryteller6belli300JadedK1lltasticTiago1980MagrailothosVivek_786RichTheManHeadrollerClintonwalls101AromaticCoffeeDOKTOROKTOPUSBruce12342SpiderCoolsSlayerOfGodsRaymundo86WerewrymPanchulon21 35 votes
No
38%
Alex_sc11MegaSkater672StarKingmum_m2FrostyKDoggg2017Alex13369Foxhero007hendroidsvWillis1519Furious_Fighter1Cadillac_puss123taojay1KerneasDRTOCh1efsterPaytoPlayColonaut123spaceoctopusKRONOSDOUBLE 22 votes

Comments

  • From a game mechanism no as it is not technically a buff, but from a comic book perspective yes. Rogue is able to steel any other mutants ability. So if she was to touch Emma Frost she would steel her ability to turn to diamonds. Given this she should be able to steel it, however not sure how that would work in the game. But in a match-up against Emma Frost I don't see it really benefiting Rogue much so probably not something worth lobbying for.
  • Yes
    I voted yes because it would be cool to see but I have a feeling if they actually tried it the game would crash forever.
  • KerneasKerneas Posts: 261
    No
    Like...Imagine her SP3. She'd replicate the form multiple times, or at least both forms at once, which would be OP, right ?
  • No
    It's not even a buff. I get that she can steal powers in the comics and movies but that doesn't matter cuz it's not how it works in this game. I mean, if we went by everybody's powers from the comics in this game, then there wouldn't even be a contest cuz phoenix would've destroyed everyone
  • Yes
    Not because I think it’s a thing that SHOULD happen, but because it’d be a thing that I’d WANT to happen
  • But again, comics are almost irrelevant to the game mechanics. They only matter to some abilities, and sometimes not even that
  • IrohrIrohr Posts: 254
    But again, comics are almost irrelevant to the game mechanics. They only matter to some abilities, and sometimes not even that

    Thank you Captain Obvious. That was stated.
  • Yes
    Just gonna drop the fact that Rogue gained Moon Knights MULTIPLE PERSONALITY DISORDER.

    pjby2c2nprq9.jpg
    No. Is not a buff

    Would you consider a multiple personality disorder to be a buff? I don't think so.
    But again, comics are almost irrelevant to the game mechanics. They only matter to some abilities, and sometimes not even that

    Yes, The Contests storyline is much different then the actual comics or movies, making it a big puzzle with random pieces that don't fit together. But at what point did we start nerfing a Champions abilities because it was inconvient to update/make?
    I voted yes because it would be cool to see but I have a feeling if they actually tried it the game would crash forever.

    Good point.
    Pennmabob wrote: »
    It's not even a buff. I mean, if we went by everybody's powers from the comics in this game, then there wouldn't even be a contest cuz phoenix would've destroyed everyone

    1. It IS a buff. It reduces damage and makes her debuff immune.
    2. We do go by most of everyone's powers. Since when was there an exception for Rogue (other then what's in her description)?
    3. Phoenix is trash, so is Sentry, even though they were great in the comics, and Blades god Tier.
    4. I don't see the big deal about Rogue being able to replicate her Diamond Form, it's not that OP, and it's only for that fight. Rogue would be even more OP if she had persistant charges, and carried the buffs from fight to fight, but she doesn't.

    All and all, I think she should be able to replicate it. She wouldn't even replicate Inverted Controls, which most would agree is the largest challenge of the Champ.


  • will-o-wispwill-o-wisp Posts: 6,483
    edited September 2018
    Just gonna drop the fact that Rogue gained Moon Knights MULTIPLE PERSONALITY DISORDER.

    pjby2c2nprq9.jpg
    No. Is not a buff

    Would you consider a multiple personality disorder to be a buff? I don't think so.

    I'm talking about the game, and your answer is based on a comic when you know and said that this game is different?
    Moon knight doesn't have a multiple personality disorder buff or ability. At least he doesn't in this game, so rogue can't replicate anything like that.

    Emma Frost's Diamond form is not a buff. Is a passive ability. And when that passive ability is triggered, she gains passive stats (and other abilities). Neither of those are buffs, apart from the Prowess.

    Again, I'm talking about the game. Buffs have their own meaning on this game.



  • No
    Just gonna drop the fact that Rogue gained Moon Knights MULTIPLE PERSONALITY DISORDER.

    pjby2c2nprq9.jpg
    No. Is not a buff

    Would you consider a multiple personality disorder to be a buff? I don't think so.
    But again, comics are almost irrelevant to the game mechanics. They only matter to some abilities, and sometimes not even that

    Yes, The Contests storyline is much different then the actual comics or movies, making it a big puzzle with random pieces that don't fit together. But at what point did we start nerfing a Champions abilities because it was inconvient to update/make?
    I voted yes because it would be cool to see but I have a feeling if they actually tried it the game would crash forever.

    Good point.
    Pennmabob wrote: »
    It's not even a buff. I mean, if we went by everybody's powers from the comics in this game, then there wouldn't even be a contest cuz phoenix would've destroyed everyone

    1. It IS a buff. It reduces damage and makes her debuff immune.
    2. We do go by most of everyone's powers. Since when was there an exception for Rogue (other then what's in her description)?
    3. Phoenix is trash, so is Sentry, even though they were great in the comics, and Blades god Tier.
    4. I don't see the big deal about Rogue being able to replicate her Diamond Form, it's not that OP, and it's only for that fight. Rogue would be even more OP if she had persistant charges, and carried the buffs from fight to fight, but she doesn't.

    All and all, I think she should be able to replicate it. She wouldn't even replicate Inverted Controls, which most would agree is the largest challenge of the Champ.


    1. Ok but even if it was a buff; it's a passive and you can't steal those. I still think that it's more of an ability than a buff.
    2. We actually miss out a lot of abilities and features of character because of something they call "balance"
    3. Um, what r u on.... I said that if we went by everyone's comic powers then there would not be a contest cuz phoenix is so op. Blade is irrelevant
    4. I know it's not a big deal and that it's not OP, never said it was.
  • Yes
    There's still remains the fact that Rogue becomes more and more irrelevant as they release more champs.
Sign In or Register to comment.