PLEASE Enable Officers to Withdraw Someone From a War BG During Placement

TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
in Suggestions and Requests
People make mistakes and join the wrong group from time to time. Also, in game chat is terrible and many are not willing to use outside chat apps to coordinate and organize teams well. It would be incredibly helpful if an officer could withdraw a person who placed their Champs in the wrong group for war.
«1

Comments

  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    Even if it was just limited to leader, something would be better than nothing, but I agree that officer level would be ideal. We have an excellent group with thorough communication, but no one can be perfect all the time.
  • PeytonMariePeytonMarie Member Posts: 51 ★
    90% of the community uses Line, Discord, Groupme, etc. Which wrong bgs isn't a problem in those allys that use them. The chq app would even work, and its geared towards the Contest.
  • ShummyeeShummyee Member Posts: 3
    I agree, sometimes people join the wrong group by accident and that throws the organisation of the group off. The ability for officers or leaders to take them out and correct it, would very helpful indeed.
  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    We do use Line, @PeytonMarie. We have excellent communication and organization, but eventually, in any alliance, you come up on this issue. It’s a small, pre-coffee error that can have very costly results. It expects everyone to join perfectly every time, and that is unrealistic. Our track record is one error every 8 months? That’s great, but it would still be nice to be able to have some authority to manipulate group make up for when that one time exists. Depending on when or who the player is who made the error, it can be too late to adjust attack and defense plans accordingly to even out the composition of battle groups.

    On a side note, a simple, thoughtful suggestion shouldn’t need to be defended. It’s an acknowledgment that errors do happen occasionally because we are all human.
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    @PeytonMarie my alliance uses Line, but people still make mistakes and join incorrectly. And as I said, there are some unwilling to use Line. But mistakes still happen and i don't agree that "wrong BGs isn't a problem in those allys that use them".
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    Thank you, @Heddarta . Very insightful.
  • HamandeggzHamandeggz Member Posts: 1
    @PeytonMarie

    I think that it's funny that someone would even respond like that in a suggestions/requests section.
    Step one, someone makes a request. Step two, you tell them they shouldn't have their request fulfilled...why?

    It's like people think that their personal experience is the only one that matters.

    The real question is: Is there a cost to fulfilling the request that would negatively harm the community?
  • unknownunknown Member Posts: 378 ★
    edited January 2018
    ANYONE that joins the wrong BG is a moron and shouldnt be allowed to play. How hard is it to hit the right button? Its not like they are so close together that it can be accidental. People join the wrong BG because they want to, not by accident. If I'm told to join BG1, I join BG1, not BG3. If they do it more than once, boot them. So simple. Dont come on here acting like people do it on accident. In the famous words of Judge Judy...Thats ridiculous.
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    Thanks for your input, @Hamandeggz :)
  • PeytonMariePeytonMarie Member Posts: 51 ★
    Well if it was possible to do im sure kabam would have done it by now. And it's not hard to adjust. Maybe because im in tier 2.
  • BossyBuilderBossyBuilder Member Posts: 137
    This would be a great feature!
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    I agree, @BossyBuilder , lol. I just think it would be a simple addition that would benefit all without harming anything.
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    To be fully transparent...lol...I was the one that made the "pre-coffee" error, as @Heddarta called it, this time around...and it was indeed pre-coffee! I would have loved to have been able to rectify this mistake as an officer.
  • TheeWolverineTheeWolverine Member Posts: 78 ★
    Lmfao! Line makes you mistake proof!
  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    I was trying to be discreet, @Tiemilios. o:)
  • SolswerdSolswerd Member Posts: 1,877 ★★★★
    I totally agree it would be a good addition to the game that would not cause any real harm. (if the Kabam servers could handle it...lol)

    In regards to "a simple, thoughtful suggestion shouldn't need to be defended", to be fair you are posting on a discussion forum where others that disagree with you are free to post their opinions. If you want to avoid that, you should PM the moderators with your idea.
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    There's nothing wrong with sharing of opinions, but I think it's been interesting how quick other players are to shoot down good ideas without a valid reason to do so or without admitting that that they could possibly make a similar mistake. And, when an idea like this doesn't hurt anything, there's not too much reason to argue against it. But, as you say, people are free to voice their opinions and that doesn't always go how you'd expect, when from simple suggestions.
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,581 ★★★★★
    I'm actually behind this one. I've had many issues with this.
  • TiemiliosTiemilios Member Posts: 337 ★
    Thanks, @GroundedWisdom . I honestly think this happens rather often...maybe not for all alliances, but certainly a good amount.
  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    A feature like this could have saved Seatin.
  • SweatlipSweatlip Member Posts: 163
    You gotta be a complete noob to place your champs in the wrong bg.
  • HeyheyheyHeyheyhey Member Posts: 84
    Amazing idea would love to have that feature
  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    Let he who is without mistakes cast stupid comments. Didn’t realize we had a perfect person on the forums, @Sweatlip.
  • SweatlipSweatlip Member Posts: 163
    Heddarta wrote: »
    Let he who is without mistakes cast stupid comments. Didn’t realize we had a perfect person on the forums, @Sweatlip.

    Haha i posted as a joke mate and then sent the screen shot to my bg. I literally just made that mistake 5 minutes before reading this thread lol
  • HeddartaHeddarta Member Posts: 106
    LOL - I was like...geez, can you even have 3 seconds after making a comment where someone doesn’t dismiss it?! Good luck in your war!
  • SweatlipSweatlip Member Posts: 163
    edited February 2018
    And i agree with the op. No need for a mistake that could be easily rectified to cost a war
  • ShadeZeroShadeZero Member Posts: 145 ★
    This is BS on kabam's part. He has always advocated for playing fair and not cheating. He is the best at displaying the champions he's been granted through the program. Without him in it the community suffers as well. He was fully transparent and honest about the situation. This should be a temporary ban from the program or the community will take action against it.
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,581 ★★★★★
    Wrong Thread bud.
  • SweatlipSweatlip Member Posts: 163
    Who is he talking about?
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,581 ★★★★★
    Sweatlip wrote: »
    Who is he talking about?

    The situation with the Content Creator that was removed. Probably clicked on the wrong Thread.
Sign In or Register to comment.