Assuming both are unduped. Currently I run a pretty weak AW defense team of four star duped SM MM, unduped Cable, Abomination and Mordo and three star 4/40 iceman.
Better AW defender - Abomination or BP CW 38 votes
Abomination (unduped)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/14117/14117e098b64c36ae4acb046f09201c12e3a0b3d" alt="Alfa_Pigeon"
2 votes
Black Panther CW (unduped)
0
Comments
"Assuming both are unduped." BPCW does not need to be duped to be a good defender. In fact duping BPCW is arguably neutral to his strength as a defender (there's some pro and con there). Abomination gains significantly from being duped because on top of procing poison when you bleed him there's a chance to generate poison whenever anyone hits him at all with a melee attack.
I think BPCW is a better defender all around, but with Abomination unawakened it becomes no contest in my opinion.
We have just played more. When I first started I had to ask how to 100% a quest because I didn't realize paths you had already ran became a solid line and dashed ones weren't done lol