My Battlegrounds disappeared [MERGED]

124

Comments

  • DrZolaDrZola Member Posts: 8,926 ★★★★★
    DNA3000 said:

    __SF__ said:

    It was NOT taken down early. It ended at midnight of the day of….

    Why do people keep saying this like it is relevant?

    First of all, BG did not go down on midnight of the 14th Pacific time. It actually went down at 11pm on the 13th.

    Second, BG did go down early: it went down eleven hours earlier than the in-game timer described, which is the *only* deadline any normal player could possibly be aware of.

    Third, Kabam didn’t actually “take down” BG. It became unavailable due to a bug, probably differential clock related. This was not an intentional disabling of the game mode.
    If it’s just internal game clock issues (which is the only logical explanation), what’s the solution?

    No guarantee players would move up, but also no guarantee they wouldn’t. Opportunities for additional points in alliance and solo mode cut short, most significantly for players who were naturally asleep in certain time zones.

    I’d think the answer is either (a) nothing, because BGs went off for everyone or (b) an additional amount of each solo and alliance prizes based loosely on where players and alliances wound up before the clock ran out.

    If (b), just don’t hold up payout trying to figure out a solution.

    Dr. Zola
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,498 ★★★★★
    DrZola said:

    DNA3000 said:

    __SF__ said:

    It was NOT taken down early. It ended at midnight of the day of….

    Why do people keep saying this like it is relevant?

    First of all, BG did not go down on midnight of the 14th Pacific time. It actually went down at 11pm on the 13th.

    Second, BG did go down early: it went down eleven hours earlier than the in-game timer described, which is the *only* deadline any normal player could possibly be aware of.

    Third, Kabam didn’t actually “take down” BG. It became unavailable due to a bug, probably differential clock related. This was not an intentional disabling of the game mode.
    If it’s just internal game clock issues (which is the only logical explanation), what’s the solution?

    No guarantee players would move up, but also no guarantee they wouldn’t. Opportunities for additional points in alliance and solo mode cut short, most significantly for players who were naturally asleep in certain time zones.

    I’d think the answer is either (a) nothing, because BGs went off for everyone or (b) an additional amount of each solo and alliance prizes based loosely on where players and alliances wound up before the clock ran out.

    If (b), just don’t hold up payout trying to figure out a solution.

    Dr. Zola
    That's a difficult slope to ascend. How do you quantify potential? You can't provide what people *may* have done.
  • DrZolaDrZola Member Posts: 8,926 ★★★★★
    edited November 2022

    DrZola said:

    DNA3000 said:

    __SF__ said:

    It was NOT taken down early. It ended at midnight of the day of….

    Why do people keep saying this like it is relevant?

    First of all, BG did not go down on midnight of the 14th Pacific time. It actually went down at 11pm on the 13th.

    Second, BG did go down early: it went down eleven hours earlier than the in-game timer described, which is the *only* deadline any normal player could possibly be aware of.

    Third, Kabam didn’t actually “take down” BG. It became unavailable due to a bug, probably differential clock related. This was not an intentional disabling of the game mode.
    If it’s just internal game clock issues (which is the only logical explanation), what’s the solution?

    No guarantee players would move up, but also no guarantee they wouldn’t. Opportunities for additional points in alliance and solo mode cut short, most significantly for players who were naturally asleep in certain time zones.

    I’d think the answer is either (a) nothing, because BGs went off for everyone or (b) an additional amount of each solo and alliance prizes based loosely on where players and alliances wound up before the clock ran out.

    If (b), just don’t hold up payout trying to figure out a solution.

    Dr. Zola
    That's a difficult slope to ascend. How do you quantify potential? You can't provide what people *may* have done.
    You can’t. Which is why I suggest doing nothing (a) as a possible approach.

    Personally, I don’t think that’s the best approach, but neither do I think there’s any defensible way to estimate where players *might* have wound up.

    Easiest thing is to toss an additional amount of shards and BG tokens to everyone in a separate message. Scaling the contents of that message is probably possible based on where each player/alliance finished when the mode went down—it doesn’t make sense to award the same compensatory amounts to Celestial, Platinum and Bronze players.

    Dr. Zola
  • DNA3000DNA3000 Member, Guardian Posts: 19,359 Guardian
    DrZola said:

    DNA3000 said:

    __SF__ said:

    It was NOT taken down early. It ended at midnight of the day of….

    Why do people keep saying this like it is relevant?

    First of all, BG did not go down on midnight of the 14th Pacific time. It actually went down at 11pm on the 13th.

    Second, BG did go down early: it went down eleven hours earlier than the in-game timer described, which is the *only* deadline any normal player could possibly be aware of.

    Third, Kabam didn’t actually “take down” BG. It became unavailable due to a bug, probably differential clock related. This was not an intentional disabling of the game mode.
    If it’s just internal game clock issues (which is the only logical explanation), what’s the solution?

    No guarantee players would move up, but also no guarantee they wouldn’t. Opportunities for additional points in alliance and solo mode cut short, most significantly for players who were naturally asleep in certain time zones.

    I’d think the answer is either (a) nothing, because BGs went off for everyone or (b) an additional amount of each solo and alliance prizes based loosely on where players and alliances wound up before the clock ran out.

    If (b), just don’t hold up payout trying to figure out a solution.

    Dr. Zola
    I'm not saying there's "a solution" because you cannot unring bells, but that doesn't mean there's no problem. In situations like this there's no way to make everyone perfectly whole, because there's no way to answer the counter-factual "what would have happened." However, people lost opportunities and in some cases currencies, and that isn't just a matter of the competition being cut short. Kabam could at their discretion say well, there's nothing we can do, and that's their call. But people saying there's actually no problem at all because "it ended when it was supposed to" are not just wrong, they are wrong in multiple ways.

    Also, I do not believe this is a simple matter of the clock being set wrong. If that was the case they probably could have restored access to BGs last night. This may have been set off by Yet Another DST Issue, but the dominos that were triggered off appears, based on the very limited and incomplete information I have, to be more than just something ending early.
  • DNA3000DNA3000 Member, Guardian Posts: 19,359 Guardian
    Mauled said:

    Hey all, I have confirmed that the team is aware and we're looking into what happened here. We're not sure why this happened yet but will update you all when I have more information.

    Please remember that we do not have an active member of the Community/Kabam team in the Forums 24/7, and that, especially on weekends at midnight, you might not hear back from us right away.

    That’s completely understandable, we’ve all got to have a work/life balance. What I would say is that it’s probably worth considering shifting the timings of some of these content releases. A lot of them do seem coincide with times that Kabam employees will most likely be out of office and in the event of something going belly up there’s often an 8 hour lag on the resolution.
    In this specific case, the event was supposed to end when everyone was in the office, and incorrectly ended almost twelve hours earlier when everyone wasn't in the office. That was not something that could be planned for.

    There are times when things are explicitly scheduled to happen at poor coverage times, and that should be kept to a minimum. But this wasn't one of those times.
  • frodo2377frodo2377 Member Posts: 315 ★★★
    As far as a 24/7 support staff goes it depends on your company view. I've expressed this to Kabam before. You're either a global company or you aren't. My opinion is that if you cater to a global audience....you should staff for that. If you don't....you can't consider yourself a global company and should express that to your customer base.
  • Ceo_WakefordCeo_Wakeford Member Posts: 119

    Hey all, we have posted an update here: https://forums.playcontestofchampions.com/en/discussion/319321/battlegrounds-season-2-ending-early/p1?new=1

    "Due to an issue still under investigation, Season 2 of Battlegrounds ended 12 hours earlier than expected.

    Unfortunately, we cannot extend the already concluded Season without potentially risking other significant issues.

    To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.

    We are very sorry for this issue, and are working to ensure that it does not happen in the future."

    Thnx ,when will rewards sent ? Today or we need couple days more ?
  • AntsiouAntsiou Member Posts: 184 ★★

    Hey all, we have posted an update here: https://forums.playcontestofchampions.com/en/discussion/319321/battlegrounds-season-2-ending-early/p1?new=1

    "Due to an issue still under investigation, Season 2 of Battlegrounds ended 12 hours earlier than expected.

    Unfortunately, we cannot extend the already concluded Season without potentially risking other significant issues.

    To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.

    We are very sorry for this issue, and are working to ensure that it does not happen in the future."

    Thnx ,when will rewards sent ? Today or we need couple days more ?
    Statement says:
    “ To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.”
    So next week would be my guess.

  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,498 ★★★★★
    Antsiou said:

    Hey all, we have posted an update here: https://forums.playcontestofchampions.com/en/discussion/319321/battlegrounds-season-2-ending-early/p1?new=1

    "Due to an issue still under investigation, Season 2 of Battlegrounds ended 12 hours earlier than expected.

    Unfortunately, we cannot extend the already concluded Season without potentially risking other significant issues.

    To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.

    We are very sorry for this issue, and are working to ensure that it does not happen in the future."

    Thnx ,when will rewards sent ? Today or we need couple days more ?
    Statement says:
    “ To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.”
    So next week would be my guess.

    I believe they meant the Season Rewards.
  • MauledMauled Member, Guardian Posts: 3,957 Guardian
    DNA3000 said:

    Mauled said:

    Hey all, I have confirmed that the team is aware and we're looking into what happened here. We're not sure why this happened yet but will update you all when I have more information.

    Please remember that we do not have an active member of the Community/Kabam team in the Forums 24/7, and that, especially on weekends at midnight, you might not hear back from us right away.

    That’s completely understandable, we’ve all got to have a work/life balance. What I would say is that it’s probably worth considering shifting the timings of some of these content releases. A lot of them do seem coincide with times that Kabam employees will most likely be out of office and in the event of something going belly up there’s often an 8 hour lag on the resolution.
    In this specific case, the event was supposed to end when everyone was in the office, and incorrectly ended almost twelve hours earlier when everyone wasn't in the office. That was not something that could be planned for.

    There are times when things are explicitly scheduled to happen at poor coverage times, and that should be kept to a minimum. But this wasn't one of those times.
    Oh I realise that in this case the scheduling wasn’t the issue but there does seem to be a trend of things going wrong on a Friday evening/weekend that aren’t able to be resolved until the new working week.

    Maybe a lot of stuff goes wrong during the week that’s immediately caught before we’re able to take notice of it and activate grumble mode. Considering the revenue this product makes and its global audience, having one poor soul monitoring the forums overnight with a techy fellow who’s able to triage or investigate so at least when the day crew come in it can immediately be resolved would be worth the investment.


    Can’t fault the response though in this case.
  • Erza_ScarletErza_Scarlet Member Posts: 130
    Antsiou said:

    Hey all, we have posted an update here: https://forums.playcontestofchampions.com/en/discussion/319321/battlegrounds-season-2-ending-early/p1?new=1

    "Due to an issue still under investigation, Season 2 of Battlegrounds ended 12 hours earlier than expected.

    Unfortunately, we cannot extend the already concluded Season without potentially risking other significant issues.

    To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.

    We are very sorry for this issue, and are working to ensure that it does not happen in the future."

    Thnx ,when will rewards sent ? Today or we need couple days more ?
    Statement says:
    “ To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.”
    So next week would be my guess.

    He asked about rewards though....not the compensation
  • AntsiouAntsiou Member Posts: 184 ★★
    Oh my bad, I misread.
  • Trafalgarwar96Trafalgarwar96 Member Posts: 541 ★★★

    Hey all, we have posted an update here: https://forums.playcontestofchampions.com/en/discussion/319321/battlegrounds-season-2-ending-early/p1?new=1

    "Due to an issue still under investigation, Season 2 of Battlegrounds ended 12 hours earlier than expected.

    Unfortunately, we cannot extend the already concluded Season without potentially risking other significant issues.

    To make up for this, we will be giving all players a package of Elder’s Marks, Trophy Tokens and Victory Shields as an apology when the next season starts.

    We are very sorry for this issue, and are working to ensure that it does not happen in the future."

    We can change ally or we will lose this rewards? They are different from the season rewards, aren t they?
  • DNA3000DNA3000 Member, Guardian Posts: 19,359 Guardian
    frodo2377 said:

    As far as a 24/7 support staff goes it depends on your company view. I've expressed this to Kabam before. You're either a global company or you aren't. My opinion is that if you cater to a global audience....you should staff for that. If you don't....you can't consider yourself a global company and should express that to your customer base.

    Kabam is not a global company. Kabam is a development studio with offices in Canada and the US. As far as I'm aware, they have never claimed to be a planetary defense network.

    Other companies I work with that are not global companies by this definition. Microsoft, Cisco, Vmware, Oracle. Try getting a hold of anyone at those companies after hours without paying hundreds of dollars an hour.

    Another company that does not pass your global company definition: Youtube. Try getting a hold of anyone at any time when something goes wrong. They have 24 hour operations, but they don't even have one hour customer facing support.

    Once upon a time, back when licensing worked differently, if you ran into a license reset issue with Checkpoint firewalls you often couldn't resolve that issue on Friday, not for any amount of money. That's because Checkpoint was headquartered in Israel, which was over the dateline, which made Friday in the US (more or less) Saturday over there which was the Sabbath. At the time, Checkpoint was the largest global supplier of enterprise firewalls in the world. But apparently not a global company.
  • DrZolaDrZola Member Posts: 8,926 ★★★★★
    DNA3000 said:

    DrZola said:

    DNA3000 said:

    __SF__ said:

    It was NOT taken down early. It ended at midnight of the day of….

    Why do people keep saying this like it is relevant?

    First of all, BG did not go down on midnight of the 14th Pacific time. It actually went down at 11pm on the 13th.

    Second, BG did go down early: it went down eleven hours earlier than the in-game timer described, which is the *only* deadline any normal player could possibly be aware of.

    Third, Kabam didn’t actually “take down” BG. It became unavailable due to a bug, probably differential clock related. This was not an intentional disabling of the game mode.
    If it’s just internal game clock issues (which is the only logical explanation), what’s the solution?

    No guarantee players would move up, but also no guarantee they wouldn’t. Opportunities for additional points in alliance and solo mode cut short, most significantly for players who were naturally asleep in certain time zones.

    I’d think the answer is either (a) nothing, because BGs went off for everyone or (b) an additional amount of each solo and alliance prizes based loosely on where players and alliances wound up before the clock ran out.

    If (b), just don’t hold up payout trying to figure out a solution.

    Dr. Zola
    I'm not saying there's "a solution" because you cannot unring bells, but that doesn't mean there's no problem. In situations like this there's no way to make everyone perfectly whole, because there's no way to answer the counter-factual "what would have happened." However, people lost opportunities and in some cases currencies, and that isn't just a matter of the competition being cut short. Kabam could at their discretion say well, there's nothing we can do, and that's their call. But people saying there's actually no problem at all because "it ended when it was supposed to" are not just wrong, they are wrong in multiple ways.

    Also, I do not believe this is a simple matter of the clock being set wrong. If that was the case they probably could have restored access to BGs last night. This may have been set off by Yet Another DST Issue, but the dominos that were triggered off appears, based on the very limited and incomplete information I have, to be more than just something ending early.
    Sounds more complex than I would have thought. They can just double all my rewards then and I will be fine.

    Dr. Zola
  • frodo2377frodo2377 Member Posts: 315 ★★★
    DNA3000 said:

    frodo2377 said:

    As far as a 24/7 support staff goes it depends on your company view. I've expressed this to Kabam before. You're either a global company or you aren't. My opinion is that if you cater to a global audience....you should staff for that. If you don't....you can't consider yourself a global company and should express that to your customer base.

    Kabam is not a global company. Kabam is a development studio with offices in Canada and the US. As far as I'm aware, they have never claimed to be a planetary defense network.

    Other companies I work with that are not global companies by this definition. Microsoft, Cisco, Vmware, Oracle. Try getting a hold of anyone at those companies after hours without paying hundreds of dollars an hour.

    Another company that does not pass your global company definition: Youtube. Try getting a hold of anyone at any time when something goes wrong. They have 24 hour operations, but they don't even have one hour customer facing support.

    Once upon a time, back when licensing worked differently, if you ran into a license reset issue with Checkpoint firewalls you often couldn't resolve that issue on Friday, not for any amount of money. That's because Checkpoint was headquartered in Israel, which was over the dateline, which made Friday in the US (more or less) Saturday over there which was the Sabbath. At the time, Checkpoint was the largest global supplier of enterprise firewalls in the world. But apparently not a global company.
    I work IT support that staffs 24x7 for customers/clients. I guess I work for a planetary defense network. Cool.

    I expect our vendors to be available to answer support related questions 24x7 since we are staffed for that time frame. It's what we pay support for.

    I just have a different world view based on my own 30 years in IT. Everyone has different experiences. :smile:
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,498 ★★★★★

    frodo2377 said:

    DNA3000 said:

    frodo2377 said:

    As far as a 24/7 support staff goes it depends on your company view. I've expressed this to Kabam before. You're either a global company or you aren't. My opinion is that if you cater to a global audience....you should staff for that. If you don't....you can't consider yourself a global company and should express that to your customer base.

    Kabam is not a global company. Kabam is a development studio with offices in Canada and the US. As far as I'm aware, they have never claimed to be a planetary defense network.

    Other companies I work with that are not global companies by this definition. Microsoft, Cisco, Vmware, Oracle. Try getting a hold of anyone at those companies after hours without paying hundreds of dollars an hour.

    Another company that does not pass your global company definition: Youtube. Try getting a hold of anyone at any time when something goes wrong. They have 24 hour operations, but they don't even have one hour customer facing support.

    Once upon a time, back when licensing worked differently, if you ran into a license reset issue with Checkpoint firewalls you often couldn't resolve that issue on Friday, not for any amount of money. That's because Checkpoint was headquartered in Israel, which was over the dateline, which made Friday in the US (more or less) Saturday over there which was the Sabbath. At the time, Checkpoint was the largest global supplier of enterprise firewalls in the world. But apparently not a global company.
    I work IT support that staffs 24x7 for customers/clients. I guess I work for a planetary defense network. Cool.

    I expect our vendors to be available to answer support related questions 24x7 since we are staffed for that time frame. It's what we pay support for.

    I just have a different world view based on my own 30 years in IT. Everyone has different experiences. :smile:
    The forums are to discuss MCOC, not to discuss how Game Studios/Kabam differ from other kinds of Tech companies, so we're putting a stop to this conversation right now. You can reach a 24x7 Customer Service team in-game through the Settings Menu.
    This. The Forum is a discussion board first and foremost. It's not Support.
  • Eugene_VirtuosoEugene_Virtuoso Member Posts: 371



    Although the times were not posted, the weekly “turnover” happened at midnight (PST) everytime. The season started at midnight on Oct 17. Although the game timer was off, it does say in the original posting it ends on Nov 14. This is how the first season was as well.

    Not exactly, I was able to make a final push last season at around this time. The timer is our guide and it being off isn't out fault. If at all it was off, kabam owes us compensation for misleading us.
    I don't understand why there is so much disagreeing on my comment, yet Kabam apologized for the timing issue and offered compensation, which we are grateful for. You'd think I said something wrong or spoke of something that won't benefit everyone. Honestly some people in this community are so negative it's astonishing. Stop being so awful and unreasonable, just disliking peoples' comments for no reason.
  • GroundedWisdomGroundedWisdom Member Posts: 36,498 ★★★★★
    Tainted said:

    frodo2377 said:

    DNA3000 said:

    frodo2377 said:

    As far as a 24/7 support staff goes it depends on your company view. I've expressed this to Kabam before. You're either a global company or you aren't. My opinion is that if you cater to a global audience....you should staff for that. If you don't....you can't consider yourself a global company and should express that to your customer base.

    Kabam is not a global company. Kabam is a development studio with offices in Canada and the US. As far as I'm aware, they have never claimed to be a planetary defense network.

    Other companies I work with that are not global companies by this definition. Microsoft, Cisco, Vmware, Oracle. Try getting a hold of anyone at those companies after hours without paying hundreds of dollars an hour.

    Another company that does not pass your global company definition: Youtube. Try getting a hold of anyone at any time when something goes wrong. They have 24 hour operations, but they don't even have one hour customer facing support.

    Once upon a time, back when licensing worked differently, if you ran into a license reset issue with Checkpoint firewalls you often couldn't resolve that issue on Friday, not for any amount of money. That's because Checkpoint was headquartered in Israel, which was over the dateline, which made Friday in the US (more or less) Saturday over there which was the Sabbath. At the time, Checkpoint was the largest global supplier of enterprise firewalls in the world. But apparently not a global company.
    I work IT support that staffs 24x7 for customers/clients. I guess I work for a planetary defense network. Cool.

    I expect our vendors to be available to answer support related questions 24x7 since we are staffed for that time frame. It's what we pay support for.

    I just have a different world view based on my own 30 years in IT. Everyone has different experiences. :smile:
    The forums are to discuss MCOC, not to discuss how Game Studios/Kabam differ from other kinds of Tech companies, so we're putting a stop to this conversation right now. You can reach a 24x7 Customer Service team in-game through the Settings Menu.
    While what you say is partially true, the way you say it, as always, is rude and passive aggressive as per ur usual behavior. You guys are constantly ruining so many game modes in so many ways and then when a guy comes and say "because ur game has so many bugs, you gotta have better presence IT wise", ur basically telling him to foff. It`s easy : stop making bugs at a better rate than even new content and people won`t tell you to have support 24/7 (even if that is the standard in any gaming company). And you .... you gotta get in soft skills training, you cannot abuse ur clients verbally when they give you polite feedback.
    This is an example of why responses are given in a direct manner. It's not abusive. It's their responsibility to moderate the Forum, and when issues become off-topic, or become a dog pile of issues, they're going to put it back on track.
    The Forum is first and foremost a place for us to discuss the game. They're not here for the express purpose of communicating with the Staff or Devs. It's not a Walkie-Talkie to Kabam. I'm sorry if that offends you, but it's been stated many times, including in the Rules of the Forum, which can and should be read by everyone.
    As for your comment about bugs, it's also been clarified many times by Players and Kabam that making less content isn't going to fix ongoing issues. They're two separate aspects of development. On a side note, it would neuter the data that helps work on the issues.
    Perhaps your perception was that Miike's comments were abusive, but I don't see abuse from that. They're Moderators. It's their job.
  • Satishp975Satishp975 Member Posts: 5
    edited November 2022
    Mackey said:

    Kappa2g said:

    You would think that an in game timer which everyone can see displaying the hours and minutes left that ticks down consistently would be accurate and be the final say over a date posted on the forums with no specific time listed... apparently not. What's even the point of the timer in game then if we can't trust it?

    That's the best thing about it, the date did correspond with the in game timer, it should of ended in about 9.5 hours. Trust kabam to get it wrong on 2 fronts 😂
    Yes Kabam please respond
Sign In or Register to comment.