**Mastery Loadouts**
Due to issues related to the release of Mastery Loadouts, the "free swap" period will be extended.
The new end date will be May 1st.
Due to issues related to the release of Mastery Loadouts, the "free swap" period will be extended.
The new end date will be May 1st.
Comments
And the proposed "fix" doesn't even change it a tiny bit. Just creates another problem for everyone else
Agreed, I think to many people are missing the point, or just want to complain to complain. I can’t wait for the event. My whole family plays this and we always gift each other stuff.
I think you're asking if the restrictions are fair to the players who attempted to take advantage of the opportunity, and I'm a bit torn on that one. On the one hand, making alts explicitly to farm easy units to gift back to yourself is obviously not intended. Anyone who did that was taking a risk, because that could fall into the range of being exploitive, and when exploits are cracked down upon there's always some collateral damage: no exploit countermeasure is scalpel perfect. So if someone rolled a dozen alts last week to attempt to do this, in my opinion they took their chances and have to accept the risks involved with that kind of activity. I don't have tons of sympathy for those players: that's what risk is: sometimes you win, sometimes you lose.
On the other hand, the restrictions are high enough that they can catch other players, particularly new players playing their first account in particular. I do have more sympathy for those players. I have *some* sympathy for players who play multiple alts completely independently of the gifting event as well. I think the limitations are higher than they need to be relative to these players, but I don't know how much lower they could safely be lowered before you start to lose the effectiveness of the limitations in the first place.
When it comes to the level restriction specifically, which I think is probably the most iffy one, I think 30 is too low to be effective, and 40 is probably higher than it needs to be. But everything in between is pretty grey on the trade off between effectiveness and over cautious.
I should point out that the restrictions don't prevent anyone from alt-farming. They act to limit the ability to skim the easiest rewards that were added to the early game experience. Because they are sort of "proof of work" restrictions (to use a term of art in the cryptocurrency community) they aren't going to distinguish between "normal" accounts and "gifting alts" they will distinguish between levels of effort. So a player that wants to put more effort into pushing a gifting alt will meet the requirements easier than a player that has less time to play but is playing a main. That's unfortunate, but I don't have an easy solution to that one.
I did have completely different *ideas* that I thought would work better because they side-stepped these kinds of issues (in particular early game currency) but I don't know if there were technical limitations on that idea, or if I'm just way smarter than the Kabam developers (kidding). And I'm pretty sure if they had implemented my idea instead, there would be tons of people saying it was unfair and I stole their Christmas and probably wishing harm upon my dog (although for the record, I don't have a dog).
The date gate is of course trivial to bypass, because Brian Grant didn't invent alt farming. It has been going on for some time, not just in terms of the gifting event, but also arena bots. There are probably thousands of alts rolled up constantly for these purposes, and likely thousands available to be used before Brian made his video. Any creation date gate alone catches the burst of people who decided to give this a try right now, but fails to catch people who might have started a while ago, or might be repurposing alts for this purpose (after realizing it is more profitable than whatever they were originally intending). It catches some stuff so it is worth having this gate, but it doesn't catch enough.
The progression title one is also not perfect. We don't have a lot of fine grained control with progression titles. The alt farm accounts are almost certainly going to have explored Act 3. The next higher title is Conqueror with Act 4 completion, then Uncollected with Act 5.2 completion. Uncollected is of course too high of a gate. But Conqueror is not very much higher than what we already know the accounts will do. It proves the account went beyond Act 3. It doesn't prove that wasn't done deliberately just to pass the gate. Once again it catches some stuff (accounts that stop at Act 3) but doesn't catch enough.
The level gate is probably the harshest on paper, but it is also flawed. It is going to catch almost all of the accounts that are hand played to Act 3. It cannot catch accounts that are hand played to Act 3 then botted for XP until they reach level 40. I'm honestly not sure how long that would take, but I'm guessing its possible between now and the gifting event.
The gates each limit the qualifying accounts in different ways to in effect increase the cost of making a unit farm alt. The idea being, to make the cost high enough to make indiscriminate farming not worth the effort. I'm not saying the restrictions do that in the best possible way. I'm simply saying having multiple ones gives more control over the process.
This gets rid of the easily exploitable units, while allowing people to unit farm if they do desire on alts instead of arena.
Are there any restrictions on receiving gifts? Because it might get a little awkward if people start asking for gifts when they legitimately cannot send anything back - though maybe it's not a very big issue...?
Just kidding of course. I tend to agree with your assessment, and my main lament is excluding newer players <L40 or not quite through Act 4 from what’s *supposed* to be a holiday event. Not quite sure how you masked those accounts, other than providing a skinnied down version of the event just for them or permitting old accounts (say, before 2019) to participate even in a limited capacity. Implementation on both those would admittedly be tricky.
No matter what, it’s inevitable you’re going to make someone unhappy and willing to curse your dog.
Dr. Zola
This is fantastic news!